Focus on Counterterrorism and Strategic Information Sharing
Advocacy campaigns spearheaded by groups like Jewish Voice for Peace have sought to curtail cooperative seminars between American and Israeli law enforcement, labeling these bilateral initiatives as dangerous operations that promote discriminatory enforcement and civilian suppression.
Since 2002, JINSA has brought more than two hundred senior American security professionals to Israel and introduced many more to Israeli specialists during educational conferences in the United States. Steven Pomerantz, a former Assistant Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation who directs JINSA’s Homeland Security Program, affirmed that these programs contain no tactical physical drills. Participating officers do not receive instruction in physical restraint methods, suspect apprehension mechanics, or bodily holds. Instead, the curriculum focuses on examining the ideological motivations of suicide bombers, anticipating and thwarting terrorist attacks, defusing volatile confrontations through de-escalation, and improving inter-agency intelligence coordination.
Independent Standards and Absence from Misconduct Cases
Law enforcement officers implicated in prominent cases of police violence, including the officers involved in the killing of George Floyd, never participated in exchange programs in Israel. Furthermore, according to the Jewish Virtual Library, had those officers participated in an exchange program, no instructor in Israel would have taught them to hold a knee against a suspect's neck or to shoot an individual attempting to flee arrest.
Domestic Origins of American Policing and Antisemitic Tropes
Educational materials published by Deadly Exchange acknowledge that the operational mission of American policing was established long before Israel was founded, tracing its origins to early slave patrols and Reconstruction-era Black Codes.
Campaign materials further recognize that framing Israel as the primary catalyst or exporter of American law enforcement brutality fundamentally misplaces accountability. Promoting that distorted connection absolves domestic authorities of responsibility for local systemic challenges. Furthermore, asserting that Israeli influence orchestrates the conduct of municipal American police forces revives classic antisemitic tropes that depict Jewish people as clandestine manipulators directing state repression from behind the scenes.